• Login
  • Register

OffBeat Magazine

  • Home
  • Issue
  • News
    • Online News
    • Louisiana On Tour
    • Blogs
    • Musicians Birthdays
  • Live Music
    • Add a New Listing
  • Reviews
    • Album Reviews
    • Submit
    • New Releases
  • Watch
  • Listen
  • Food
  • Weekly Beat
  • Archive
  • Shop
  • Advertise
  • Donate
  • Subscribe!
  • The OnBeat Sessions
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Flickr
  • YouTube
  • FourSquare
  • RSS Feed
Event Search

Sean Manning (ed.), Rock and Roll Cage Match: Music’s Greatest Rivalries, Decided (Three Rivers Press)

December 1, 2008 by: Andrew Hamlin Leave a comment

 

Biggest All-Time (Rock/Pop, at Least) Music Rivalry Left Untouched: “Beatles vs. Stones,” maybe because too many readers would find the answer wrong no matter which author wrote which verdict. Finest Speaker of Truth: Richard Hell on “the Rolling Stones vs. the Velvet Underground,” where the irregular rock star and underrated scribe nails serious, subtle points heretofore undiscussed and to boot pulls back the curtain on that “front man” phenomenon (“The lead singer is a cunt. When a person needs to have that power—a godlike power enabling him to confer a feeling of immortality to his audience… that driven self-certainty will make him a creep.”) Trickiest Argument: Melissa Maerz on “Trent Reznor vs. Marilyn Manson,” where the shadings within Manson’s fakery ultimately trump Reznor’s not-too-carefully hidden naked urge for niceness. Could Have Had a Serious Point: Russ Meneve on “Bruce Springsteen vs. Bon Jovi”—Meneve comes right to the edge of convincing me the “Wanted Dead or Alive” guy trumps the “Born to Run” guy, but settles for the funnyman rhetoric marking his day job doing stand-up. Most Missed From a New Orleans Stance: Nobody essayed “MGs vs. Meters,” a.k.a. “You want your beats solid and irrefutably snappy as the gaps between freight cars glimpsed at the railroad crossing, or slippery enough to suggest, as you listen awestruck, cosmoses, multiverses, vast complex systems dreamt between pops on Zig’s snare?”

BookmarkPopRockRolling StonesThe Beatles

Post navigation

Previous PostGraduation DayNext PostTrombone Shorty
  • About OffBeat
  • Advertise
  • Newsletter
  • Best of the Beat Award Winners
  • Contact Us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Flickr
  • YouTube
  • FourSquare
  • RSS Feed

400 Esplanade Avenue (in the New Orleans Jazz Museum),
New Orleans, LA 70116

offbeat@offbeat.com504-944-4300

icon

© 2025 OffBeat MagazineWebsite by Westguard Solutions

Offbeat Magazine
  • ISSUE
  • LIVE MUSIC
  • VIDEOS
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • SHOP
Create a new list